The Shape of Change

How Geometric Morphometrics is Revolutionizing Fish Science

Explore the Science

Introduction

Imagine trying to describe the subtle differences between two fish species—perhaps one inhabits a fast-flowing river while another lives in a tranquil lake. For centuries, scientists relied on simple measurements: length, height, the position of fins. But what if you could capture the complete geometry of their bodies, quantifying every curve and angle with mathematical precision? What if you could visualize exactly how their shapes have evolved to suit their environments?

This is the power of geometric morphometrics, a revolutionary scientific approach that has transformed how biologists study shape and form. By combining geometry, statistics, and biology, researchers can now answer questions that were once impossible to address: How do fish adapt to different habitats? Can we identify distinct populations within the same species? How does body shape relate to feeding habits or swimming ability? 1

In fish studies, this technique has opened a window into the hidden world of morphological adaptation, allowing scientists to decode the subtle relationships between form, function, and environment. From conservation biology to aquaculture, geometric morphometrics is providing unprecedented insights into the lives of these aquatic creatures.

The Shape of Science: What Exactly is Geometric Morphometrics?

At its core, geometric morphometrics is a sophisticated method for quantifying and analyzing biological shapes. Unlike traditional approaches that rely on simple linear measurements, geometric morphometrics captures the precise spatial arrangement of anatomical features, preserving the geometric relationships between them throughout analysis. 4

Type I Landmarks

Precise anatomical points, such as the insertion of fins or the junction between bones, that can be identified consistently across specimens. 4

Type II Landmarks

Defined by geometric properties, like the point of maximum curvature along a body structure. 4

Type III Landmarks

Include constructed points, such as the midpoint between two anatomical features or points evenly spaced along a curve. 4

Once landmarks are digitized from images or specimens, the data undergoes Procrustes superimposition, a statistical procedure that removes differences in position, orientation, and scale, allowing researchers to focus purely on shape variation. 4 7 What remains is the essential shape information that can be analyzed using various multivariate statistical methods.

Fish Landmark Diagram
Snout Tip
Dorsal Fin
Anal Fin
Caudal Fin

Example landmark positions on a generalized fish body plan

Mapping the Scientific Landscape: Trends in Fish Geometric Morphometrics

The growth of geometric morphometrics in fish biology has been nothing short of explosive. A comprehensive review of 814 scientific articles published between 1996 and 2023 reveals a consistent increase in publications, with notable peaks between 2016 and 2021. 1 This surge reflects the technique's expanding utility across various aspects of fish research.

Research Publications Over Time (1996-2023)
1996-2007
2008-2015
2016-2023

Relative proportion of geometric morphometrics publications in fish studies across three time periods 1

Research Themes Evolution

1996-2007

Early studies focused on adaptation, morphological variability, and geographical variation, with particular emphasis on ecomorphology—the relationship between form and ecological function. 1

2008-2015

Research expanded to investigate shape variation throughout the life cycle and deeper evolutionary processes. 1

2016-2023

Recent work has predominantly addressed the evolution of body shape, with significant focus on cyprinids (the carp family) and other economically or ecologically important groups. 1

Application Areas

Stock Discrimination

Identifying distinct populations within commercially important species for improved fisheries management. 1 9

Taxonomic Clarification

Resolving classification issues among closely related species. 1

Ecomorphology

Linking morphological variation to ecological factors and feeding strategies. 1 9

A Closer Look: Decoding Sexual Dimorphism in Tambaqui

To understand how geometric morphometrics works in practice, let's examine a compelling recent study on the tambaqui (Colossoma macropomum), an important South American fish species. This research illustrates the power of geometric morphometrics to reveal subtle morphological differences that would be difficult to detect with traditional methods.

Methodology

Researchers designed a meticulous approach to determine whether male and female tambaqui display distinct body shapes and whether these differences could be used for reliable sex identification:

  1. Specimen Preparation: The study examined adult tambaqui specimens maintained in controlled aquarium conditions.
  2. Landmark Placement: Nineteen specific anatomical landmarks were digitized on each fish.
  3. Data Analysis: The coordinate data underwent Generalized Procrustes Analysis followed by statistical testing.

Key Findings

The analysis revealed significant morphological differences between male and female tambaqui. The most distinguishing anatomical regions for sex differentiation included:

  • The posterior end of the supraoccipital bone
  • The insertion point of the pectoral fin
  • The anterior parts of the dorsal and anal fins

Visualizations created through wireframe warp plots provided intuitive representations of these morphological differences, clearly showing how specific body regions varied consistently between males and females.

Shape Differences Between Male and Female Tambaqui
Anatomical Region Males Females
Supraoccipital bone Positioned more posteriorly Positioned more anteriorly
Pectoral fin Located more dorsally Located more ventrally
Body depth Generally greater Generally lesser

Based on data from

The Scientist's Toolkit: Essential Resources for Geometric Morphometrics

Conducting geometric morphometrics research requires specialized software and tools designed to capture, process, and analyze shape data. While the specific tools may vary depending on the research question and organism, several key resources appear consistently across studies: 2 3 4 6 7

Image Acquisition

Digital cameras with macro lenses for high-resolution specimen photography. 2

TPSDig2

Widely used program for collecting landmark coordinates from digital images. 4

MorphoJ

Specialized program for performing various morphometric analyses. 4

R Packages

Powerful open-source tools for advanced statistical analysis and visualization. 4

This software ecosystem continues to evolve rapidly, with new tools and packages emerging to address increasingly complex research questions. The availability of both commercial and open-source options has made geometric morphometrics accessible to researchers across the world. 3 4 6

Conclusion: The Expanding Frontier of Shape Analysis

Geometric morphometrics has fundamentally transformed how biologists study fish diversity, evolution, and ecology. By providing a rigorous, quantitative framework for analyzing form, this approach has revealed patterns of variation and adaptation that were previously invisible to scientific inquiry. From distinguishing fish stocks for sustainable management to decoding the developmental pathways that shape bodies, geometric morphometrics has become an indispensable tool in modern ichthyology.

As the field continues to evolve, researchers are integrating morphometric data with genetic, environmental, and behavioral information to create more comprehensive understanding of biological systems. Technical advances in three-dimensional imaging and artificial intelligence-assisted landmarking promise to further expand the possibilities of this approach. 9

"Geometric morphometrics enables the quantification of organismal body shape through landmarks and semi-landmarks, providing valuable insights into ecology, evolution, and systematics."

Scientific literature review 1

The journey from simple linear measurements to sophisticated geometric analyses represents more than just technical progress—it reflects a fundamental shift in how we perceive and quantify biological form. As geometric morphometrics continues to mature and integrate with other scientific disciplines, it will undoubtedly continue to reveal new insights into the magnificent diversity of fish shapes and the evolutionary processes that have generated them.

References